The Aspen Club Has Until Dec. 31 to Show It Is Really Back

November 5, 2026

Stone and timber home exterior with a bronze-framed window, granite approach and light snow beside a blue spruce.

At the end of Ute Avenue there is now a forklift, a crane, an excavator and a skid steer working around the old clubhouse. A site office stands where there was none last spring. The Aspen Daily News counted about a dozen workers in hard hats from a single spot at the construction gate. From the Ute Trail, the site still looks like a dirt-brown postage stamp. In the middle stands a 50-year-old clubhouse frame of concrete and steel, and 14 partly built townhomes line the edges.

The City of Aspen has made Dec. 31, 2026 the last day for clubhouse construction to resume, and the city does not expect to grant any further extensions. The public benefits East Aspen was promised in 2010 are also on a deadline. One of them, a community fund, expires in 2035, and none of the benefits have arrived yet.

The Permit Date

The club closed for redevelopment in 2016, and the closure was supposed to last less than a year. In mid-April this year, chief building official Bonnie Muhigirwa granted the latest in a series of permit extensions. It came with two conditions. Crews had to keep doing substantial work on the townhomes, including reroofing, framing and flashing. And if clubhouse work had not restarted by Dec. 31, 2026, the clubhouse permit would become invalid.

Muhigirwa called it a "drop-dead" deadline, as the Daily News reported. Her April letter to the project team also shut off the usual way projects buy more time:

"Requesting amendments to land use approvals or submitting additional change orders will not constitute good cause for justifying additional extensions. Given the numerous extensions and lack of substantial activity on the site, it is unlikely that further extension requests will be granted."

The city used to accept small bursts of work as enough to keep every permit alive. Work on the townhomes, for example, kept the clubhouse permit active too. In September, Muhigirwa told Aspen Journalism that the old pattern was over. "Previously, we would see a little bit of electrical work being done, and then nothing for six months, and then another tiny bit of framing," she said. "This needs to be a real return to work on the site."

As of late October, the signs were moving the right way. Crossland Construction replaced PCL as general contractor this summer. The city confirmed concrete-slab inspections on the club building in the preceding few weeks. Muhigirwa said she believes the Dec. 31 deadline is achievable. "We are looking forward to getting this thing rolling," Crossland construction manager Austin Soder wrote to the city in early July, according to the Daily News.

How a One-Year Closure Became a Decade

The city set a hard date after ten years of stops and starts. The project's record, as reported by the Aspen Daily News:

  1. 2016: The club closes for redevelopment.
  2. 2017: Financing worth tens of millions falls through. Contractors leave the job over unpaid debts, with the townhomes 60% to 80% complete.
  3. Early 2021: The property sells at a foreclosure auction for $52.6 million to a group of Meriwether Companies, Revere Capital and Fireside Investments. A reopening is floated for winter 2023-24.
  4. 2022 and 2023: Oz Architecture's revised plans go to the city. One townhome change order clears in about six months. The others are classified as "major."
  5. 2024: The site shuts down for more than half the year, and a permit extension keeps existing permits from expiring.
  6. February 2025: Revised permits for townhomes 6 through 14 are issued after three rounds of review.
  7. April 2026: The clubhouse change order is issued after five rounds of review, more than three years after it was submitted.
  8. Summer 2026: Crossland takes over and files a construction schedule with more than 2,300 milestones.

Muhigirwa described the clubhouse review as "not unheard of for complex change orders" but "longer than most," and said the application spent significant time with both the city and the applicant.

What East Aspen Was Promised in 2010

Before 2016, the Aspen Club was more than a gym on a cul-de-sac. When Dick Butera took ownership in 1982, it was the largest private multisport facility in the nation at nearly 60,000 square feet, Aspen Public Radio reported. Tennis was his first focus, and the regulars included Billie Jean King, Martina Navratilova, Chrissy Evert, John McEnroe and Björn Borg. At its peak the club had more than 1,000 members and over 200 employees. It offered Pilates, weightlifting, basketball, physical therapy, a pool and a spa. On a tour just before the closure, owner Michael Fox told Aspen Public Radio the club had about 1,500 members. He called it "an amenity for the community."

That reputation shaped the approval. To add fractional-ownership lodging in a residential zone, the project had to show a "great public benefit." The 2010 ordinance put specific terms in writing, and they still hold despite a 2015 change to the parking and condo layout.

2010 commitment Status in fall 2026
Some community access to the club, membership or not Not delivered; the club has not reopened
Free office space for two local nonprofits Not delivered
Millions of dollars in facility upgrades Clubhouse foundation prep scheduled this fall
12 two-bedroom affordable units, open to qualified local workers through the Aspen-Pitkin County Housing Authority Construction could begin later next year under the proposed schedule
0.25% assessment on each fractional sale for a Community Health and Recreation Fund No sales closed, so nothing collected

The housing commitment was larger than it needed to be. The ordinance treated the 12 units as voluntary and above city requirements, enough to house 45% more full-time-equivalent employees than the timeshares obligated the developer to house.

The Clock That Is Already Running

The 0.25% assessment is valid for 25 years from the 2010 approval, so it sunsets in 2035. It applies only when a fractional sale closes. Developers cannot close any sales until the units receive a certificate of occupancy. The project includes 14 townhomes plus six condos still to be built inside the clubhouse.

Crossland's plan targets final inspections on the three townhome clusters in the second quarter of 2029. The affordable housing follows in the fourth quarter of 2029 and the clubhouse in the third quarter of 2030, with final completion around January 2031. If that holds, the fund can collect for about four years out of a 25-year life, as Aspen Journalism calculated. The fund was designed as a backstop. Its grants were meant to fill the gap if the club's community benefits ever went away.

The schedule also carries less weight than it appears to. The Aug. 3 construction management plan calls it a "living document." Muhigirwa said it is used for planning and information, not as a binding commitment to dates. Any slip in that schedule takes another year off the fund's collection window.

What the Site Looks Like Next

For anyone walking Ute Avenue or riding the Roaring Fork River path past the townhomes, the coming months follow Crossland's early schedule. Planned fall work includes prep on the clubhouse foundation and rough plumbing, electrical and heating. On the townhomes, the first tasks are structural investigations, any needed corrections, and water and weatherproofing work.

Those townhome checks follow years of exposure. In October, the cluster nearest completion showed weathered siding, missing panels and fractured stonework around a doorframe, and two other clusters were still under tarps. Muhigirwa said the city is generally not concerned about the existing structures. She expects the new team wants to see how everything has held up before building further.

The workforce housing depends on the pool. Site logistics put an access ramp and some materials staging on the housing parcel, so the plan calls for the clubhouse pool to be finished "as soon as possible" so the affordable units can start. Neighbors can follow progress through public updates Crossland plans to post at the site. The plan names superintendent Braden Scott as the project liaison and sole point of contact for public communication. Aspen Journalism has said its series on the club will continue in the coming weeks, covering the club's 40 years as a fitness center and the setting in which the redevelopment was approved.

A site office and a few cranes do not count as a revival on their own, Muhigirwa told Aspen Journalism. The city is watching inspections. By Dec. 31, those inspection records will show whether the clubhouse permit holds.

If you live near Ute Avenue and want to talk through how the Aspen Club's next few years could affect your corner of East Aspen, Hank Carter follows projects like this one closely. Schedule a private consultation.

Let's Get Started

Aspen has no shortage of real estate agents. What it has a shortage of is agents who have been voted the best — three times — by the community they serve. When the stakes are this high and the market this complex, experience and trust aren't optional. They're everything. That's The Carter Group.